Content Highlights
You have asserted a claim against your employer, and you are negotiating the terms of your settlement agreement. You have nailed down several points, but the next draft arrives with an agreed term removed or a new condition added. Can the other side keep changing the terms?
The answer depends on whether you are still negotiating or have formed a binding contract. Understanding that distinction can help you protect the terms you have negotiated.
When Do You Have a Meeting of the Minds?
A “meeting of the minds” means the parties have agreed on the material terms of a deal. As Cornell Law School explains, courts look at what the parties communicate and do, rather than their private assumptions. Believing you are still negotiating may not protect you if your words communicate acceptance.
Agreeing on payment may leave other important questions unresolved:
- Release: Which claims and parties will the settlement cover?
- Payment: When and how will the money be paid?
- Restrictions: Will existing contractual restrictions continue?
- Continuing obligations: Must either party provide assistance or maintain confidentiality?
- Mutual promises: Do both parties release claims against the other? Do both parties agree not to disparage the other?
Suppose you offer to accept a lower settlement amount only if the other party releases you from an existing contractual obligation. The other party agrees to the payment but refuses the release. You have agreed on a number, but a mutual release still is disputed.
Not every drafting detail must be resolved before a contract exists. The question is whether the remaining issues are essential or material and whether the parties intend to become bound as the situation exists.
What Happens When Items Come Off the List?
First, the party who is losing what he or she thought was agreed must decide whether that term is important enough to end negotiations. If not and that party continues negotiating, he or she must recognize that he or she conceded that point.
If possible, you want to get something in exchange for your concession. Both sides may make concessions as negotiations progress, but each concession should have a clear meaning.
| What happens during negotiations? | What does it mean? |
| You drop a request in exchange for increased payment. | This is a conditional trade; make the connection explicit to the other party. |
| The other party deletes a provision from a draft. | A proposed change alone does not itself establish your acceptance. |
| You “accept” but change a material condition. | Your new term is a counteroffer requiring acceptance. |
| One side revises terms after a binding agreement exists. | The revision requires the other side’s agreement. |
Cornell’s explanation of counteroffers distinguishes a materially changed offer from a request to discuss modifications. “I accept only if you remove confidentiality” communicates something different from “Would you consider removing confidentiality?”
Likewise, a provision disappearing from a draft should prompt a discussion. Was the deletion intentional? Did both sides agree? Does it change something already settled?
Keep a written record of accepted terms, unresolved issues, and conditional concessions. If individual points are resolved but the overall package remains under negotiation, communicate that distinction clearly.
Does the Agreement Have to Be Signed?
Not necessarily. Just because there is no signed document does not mean that a meeting of the minds has not occurred. This depends on whether the parties require signatures before the contract becomes binding.
Contracts may be expressed verbally or in writing. An agreement may also be implied in fact, meaning conduct demonstrates mutual agreement. A problem arises with these two types of contracts when the parties dispute the terms. Oral or implied contracts are hard to prove.
To settle a lawsuit in Texas state courts, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 11 requires the settlement to be written, signed, and filed in the court record, or made in open court and entered into the record. Other agreements may have separate requirements.
A valid contract does not need to be long and complex. The American Bar Association explains that a signed memorandum can sometimes establish a binding settlement before formal documents follow.
Before communicating acceptance, clarify:
- Have all essential terms been resolved?
- Do both sides intend to become bound now?
- Are final signatures or further approvals required?
If you intend to wait until a final agreement is signed, make that condition clear during negotiations.
Are You Protected?
Settlement negotiations involve more than reaching an acceptable number. Your concessions, conditions, and communications can affect when an agreement becomes enforceable.
At Gardner Employment Law, we help executives, professionals, and physicians evaluate proposals and protect the terms they negotiate. Contact us before committing to a settlement.
